The Subaru BRZ and Toyota GR86 represent an exciting collaboration between two automotive giants, delivering thrilling performance and sleek design in an affordable sports car package. These two rear-wheel-drive coupes share a platform and are manufactured at the same assembly plant, yet each maintains its own distinct character.
While they share many similarities, subtle differences in suspension tuning, interior features, and overall refinement set them apart. Both models highlight the benefits of this unique automotive partnership while maintaining their individual brand identities. Our team at Ciocca Subara has put together this Toyota GR86 and Subaru BRZ comparison to help you decide which model is right for you.
Under the Hood: Engine Performance and Fuel Efficiency
Both the Subaru BRZ and Toyota GR86 are powered by a 2.4-liter horizontally opposed four-cylinder boxer engine, producing 228 horsepower and 184 lb-ft of torque. This shared powerplant delivers impressive acceleration, with both cars capable of reaching 60 mph in 5.4 seconds. The engine provides strong power delivery throughout the rev range, making both cars engaging to drive on Pennsylvania roads.
Fuel efficiency ratings show both models achieve 21 mpg in city driving and 30-31 mpg on highways with the automatic transmission, while manual transmission models get 20 mpg city and 27 mpg highway. Combined fuel economy reaches 25 mpg, demonstrating a balance between performance and efficiency.
Both vehicles come standard with a six-speed manual transmission, with a six-speed automatic available as an option. The manual transmission offers precise shifts and engaging driving dynamics, while the automatic provides smooth operation and convenience for daily driving. The BRZ weighs slightly less, at 2,811 pounds, compared to the GR86's 2,820 pounds, though this minimal difference has little impact on overall performance.
Interior, Comfort, and Cargo: A Look Inside
The Subaru BRZ and Toyota GR86 feature distinct interior elements that set them apart. The BRZ comes standard with chrome interior door handles and plain black fabric seats in the base model, while the GR86 features black door handles and seats with a hexagonal G-patterned fabric. In higher trim levels, the BRZ has red interior stitching, contrasting with the GR86's silver stitching accents. The BRZ's interior design focuses on refinement and practicality, making it an excellent choice for daily drivers who appreciate attention to detail.
Both models offer modern technology features, including an 8-inch touch-screen infotainment system with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto integration. The infotainment setup includes a six-speaker sound system and dual USB 2.0 charging ports. The BRZ includes additional standard accessories, such as carpeted floor mats and a jack, which are optional in the GR86. Both vehicles feature sport bucket seats with six-way driver and four-way front passenger adjustability, providing excellent support while maintaining comfort for daily use. The BRZ offers 6.3 cubic feet of cargo space, matching the GR86's capacity and providing practical storage.
On the Road: Handling, Safety, and Reliability
The most notable differences between the BRZ and the GR86 emerge in their handling characteristics. The Subaru BRZ features aluminum steering knuckles and a chassis-mounted rear swaybar, contributing to a more stable and refined driving experience. The Toyota GR86 uses cast iron steering knuckles and a subframe-mounted rear swaybar, resulting in a slightly more aggressive handling character that you may find more engaging.
Both vehicles have achieved impressive safety credentials, receiving the 2022 Top Safety Pick + award from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety. Each model features headlight systems that earn good ratings. When equipped with the automatic transmission, both cars include front crash prevention systems that achieve superior ratings in vehicle-to-vehicle and vehicle-to-pedestrian evaluations. These achievements demonstrate both manufacturers' commitment to combining performance with safety.
Recent forum discussions have raised concerns about long-term reliability, with a significant number of users expressing apprehension about potential engine-related issues. A forum poll indicated substantial concerns, with numerous respondents reporting reliability issues. These findings suggest that you should carefully consider warranty coverage and maintenance requirements when making your purchase decision.
The Verdict: Choosing Between the Subaru BRZ and the Toyota GR86
The choice between the Subaru BRZ vs. the Toyota GR86 ultimately depends on your driving preferences and priorities. The BRZ offers a more refined and stable driving experience, making it an excellent choice for enthusiasts who plan to use their sports car as a daily driver. Its interior amenities and standard features add value for practical-minded buyers. The aluminum steering knuckles and chassis-mounted rear swaybar contribute to a more predictable handling character that you may appreciate.
The Toyota GR86 appeals to drivers seeking a more dynamic and aggressive driving experience, with its suspension tuning providing more lively handling characteristics. Both cars deliver exceptional performance, advanced safety features, and distinctive styling at similar price points, starting around $30,000. The shared platform and engine ensure that either choice gives you an engaging driving experience with impressive power delivery and handling capabilities.
Choose Your Perfect Sports Car at Ciocca Subaru
While both vehicles offer compelling packages, the BRZ's blend of performance, refinement, and daily usability makes it an excellent choice if you're seeking a well-rounded sports car experience. The included accessories, chrome interior accents, and slightly more stable handling characteristics give the BRZ additional subtle advantages that you'll appreciate in everyday use. At Ciocca Subaru of York, we encourage you to experience the Subaru BRZ firsthand. Contact us today or visit our dealership to schedule a test-drive.
Categories:
New Inventory
